Scoring - non-kicker
Points in a season
- Andy Erickson (2009): 234
- Shaun Nixon (2013): 204
- Garrett Wilson (2017): 190
- Jason Bird (2007): 168
- Cade McCrary (2008): 162
- Fred Robinson (2005): 150
- Maleek Barkley (2016): 150
- Garrett Gilbert (2008): 138
- Michael Brewer (2009): 138
- Maleek Barkley (2015): 132
Points in a career
- Shaun Nixon (2011-13): 404
- Maleek Barkley (2014-16): 318
- Andy Erickson (2007-09): 300
- Garrett Wilson (2016-18): 274
- Fred Robinson (2003-05): 264
- Michael Brewer (2008-10): 240
- Cade Green (2013-16): 234
- Griffin Gilbert (2008-11): 222
- Ben Reid (1994-96): 222
- Chris Aydam (2006-08): 212